Shared Decision-Making in Teen Mental Health Treatment

The teenage years are a time of growing independence. That’s why shared decision-making in adolescent mental health brings teens, parents, and healthcare professionals together to make informed treatment decisions. But the extent of this collaboration varies according to each teen’s needs, preferences, and circumstances.

Many young people express a wish for their parents to be involved in their care. Parents also frequently play an important role in helping teenagers access mental health services.[1] However, the benefits of parental involvement vary, and some teenagers prefer a more independent approach to treatment. 

This article explores: 

  • How parents can support their teen’s mental health while respecting their growing independence. 
  • How parental involvement can be helpful.
  • What shared decision-making is and its risks.
  • Advice for parents on promoting teen autonomy.
  • Where to find additional support.
Teenage boy sitting against wall needing support through California's Executive Order
Table of Contents

How Parental Involvement Can Help Teens

Although teens often rely on caregivers to access mental health treatment, they also need opportunities to develop autonomy and independence. These two opposing factors raise questions for teen mental health treatment, particularly around how much parents should be involved.[1][2] 

Getting Teens into Treatment

Research finds that 75% of mental health problems begin before the age of 24. Although there’s a high prevalence of mental health difficulties among teenagers, many will not seek professional support.[1] 

Some teenagers depend on parents or other trusted adults to recognize their difficulties and help them access professional support.[1]

For example, they may need a parent, friend, teacher, or sibling to help them take the first step. Between 40% and 55% of 15- to 17-year-olds report family as a major influence on them seeking help.[1] 

Another difficulty for young people seeking mental health support is that many are likely to label their distress as “normal.” They may also fear the stigma associated with mental health conditions, delaying treatment until their symptoms become difficult to manage.[1] 

Interviews with teenagers, parents, and clinicians suggest that some young people without accessible adult support may not receive help until their mental health reaches a crisis point.[1] 

In summary, parental involvement is often essential for getting teens into necessary mental health treatment. Parents can play a significant role in:[1] 

  1. Noticing when something’s wrong.
  2. Identifying that a teen’s difficulty is psychological in nature.
  3. Helping them access treatment.

During Treatment

Parental support can help protect teenagers’ mental health in several ways. Experts report that parents can reduce the risk of harm among teens experiencing:[2]

  • Romantic stress.
  • Exposure to violence.
  • Peer difficulties. 

Teen involvement in treatment is important, but parents also have valuable contributions to make. Even if it’s not in adolescent treatment decisions, parents can have a lot of influence at home by listening to teen difficulties and providing protective guidance and support.

A 2024 meta-analysis of 20 trials found that involving parents in adolescent psychological treatment produced a small overall improvement in outcomes.[2] The benefit was clearer for behavioral difficulties than for anxiety or depression. Research shows that:

  • Teens are all different: Therapeutic interventions that are “individually focused” (that is, not involving a parent or family) are effective for some teens and not for others.
  • It depends on the therapy: Effectiveness differs between different talk therapies. Parental involvement might be necessary to improve the effectiveness of non-cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) counseling, but it can also support teens in CBT to implement changes at home.
  • It might depend on age: The effectiveness of collaborative mental health care for teens can also depend on age. Younger adolescents may benefit more from parental involvement, although some older teenagers may also find it helpful. 

Parents don’t necessarily need to attend therapy sessions to provide meaningful support. Helping teens access appointments, practice coping strategies, or manage difficulties at home can also be valuable.[3]

What Is Shared Decision-Making in Teen Mental Health?

Shared decision-making (SDM) is an approach in which healthcare professionals and patients work together to make informed treatment decisions. While used in adult settings too, it’s particularly relevant to mental health care for young people. That’s because there are often more people contributing to the plan, including:[4]

  • Teens.
  • Parents.
  • Healthcare professionals.
  • Maybe other family members. 

Shared decision-making in adolescent mental health covers each stage of treatment:[4]

  • What the difficulty is.
  • How it can be best treated.
  • Who is best placed to treat the difficulty.
  • Who should be involved in treatment. 

In practice, this might mean giving a teen the opportunity to discuss different therapy options, express concerns about a proposed treatment, or explain what they hope to achieve. Their preferences can then help shape a plan that also takes clinical recommendations into account. 

The approach emerged in the 1980s to give patients a greater voice in decisions traditionally dominated by healthcare professionals. This is especially relevant for teenagers who are already gaining autonomy and independence. Experts have found that if care is not sufficiently patient-centered, outcomes aren’t as favorable.[4] 

Shared decision-making aims to strengthen the therapeutic relationship and encourage teens to participate actively in their treatment.[4] Furthermore, when parents are involved in decision-making, treatments can be better tailored to the family’s culture and strengths.[4] 

Respecting the teen voice in therapy means giving young people opportunities to express their concerns, ask questions, and influence decisions about their care.

Risks of Shared Decision-Making for Teens

Despite the benefits discussed above, there are also risks when involving parents in teen mental health treatment. For example:[2][5][3]

  • Teens might feel that they can’t trust their caregivers or mental healthcare professionals if they fail to adhere to shared decision-making promises.
  • Mental health professionals must balance their attempts to respect treatment autonomy in teens with supporting parents’ legal responsibilities to their children. For example, if there are welfare concerns, it may be in the teen’s best interest to break confidentiality and have a conversation with parents. However, teens may feel deeply betrayed by this breach of privacy.
  • 75% of child-therapist-parent triads don’t agree on the main focus of treatment, although this doesn’t mean treatment will be ineffective.
  • Some teens might feel that parental involvement is intrusive and struggle to speak openly in front of a parent. They may see it as a threat to their emotional privacy and wish to be treated like an adult.

To navigate these risks, communication between all parties is essential.

How to Preserve Teen Autonomy in Mental Health Treatment

Parents can do several things to balance being supportive for their teen during mental health challenges, while also promoting their autonomy. Here is some general guidance for this, as well as advice for navigating this balance in higher-risk scenarios:

  • Practice teen-centeredness: Some teens will want their parents to be involved in their care and others won’t. Therefore, parents should ask their teen how much involvement they would find helpful.

Joint parent-teen treatment decisions can be helpful, but a ‘hands-off’ approach might work best for some. Parents can promote teen autonomy by following their lead.[3]

  • Ask your teen what kind of support they want: Similarly, teen-centeredness involves asking direct questions about their preferences. Even if they’d rather have less parental involvement in treatment, they might want you to pick them up from sessions or help them implement lifestyle changes at home. In these ways, parents can still play a supportive role.
  •  
  • Understand the mental health difficulty and the treatment: Parents can support shared decision-making in adolescent mental health by making themselves informed. For example, understanding how CBT addresses avoidance and underlying beliefs can help parents better support a teen receiving treatment for anxiety. Having a greater understanding can help parents be supportive in a way that’s personalized to their teen’s specific difficulties.[3]

It’s also worth remembering that a teen’s preferences may change over time. Someone who initially wants their parents closely involved might become more comfortable making decisions independently as treatment progresses. Regular conversations can help everyone adjust their level of involvement accordingly.

Navigating Risk in Teen Mental Health

Shared decision-making in adolescent mental health can become more complex when high-risk behaviors are present. These may include:

Although interviewed teenagers express the need for shared decision-making, they also state a need for trust.[5]

Self-harm, suicide, and other high-risk behaviors may require parents to step in, potentially breaking the trust between themselves and their teen. Teens may feel that parents and healthcare professionals are overstepping if they:[5]

Communication and relationship-centeredness are often crucial for navigating risky mental health situations while still promoting autonomy and a teen’s voice in therapy. Where possible, parents and clinicians should explain in advance how they would respond to serious safety concerns. This may help reduce feelings of betrayal if intervention becomes necessary.[5]

smiling young men | Mission Prep Healthcare

Are You or a Loved One Struggling with Self Harm?

Mission Prep is here to help you or your loved one take the next steps towards an improved mental well-being.

Find Teen and Family Mental Health Support at Mission Prep Teen Treatment

Shared decision-making in adolescent mental health requires balancing a teen’s growing independence with their need for support and safety. Collaborative treatment planning can help families navigate these competing priorities.

At Mission Prep Teen Treatment, we promote shared decision-making for teens and their parents by offering several kinds of support. Our teen mental health treatment programs include:

  • Evidence-based therapy for teens with different mental health conditions.
  • Residential treatment stays for teens who need more involved care.
  • Virtual intensive outpatient treatment for teens looking for flexible care they can attend from home.
  • Family therapy for family members who want to repair their relationships and improve communication.
  • Family support groups for those who have children with mental health difficulties.

Mission Prep Teen Treatment accepts insurance and is in-network with many major providers. We are happy to help you check your insurance coverage for mental health care.

Contact us online or call 866-901-4047 to speak with a caring member of our team who can answer any questions you might have. Reach out for a free, no-obligation conversation.

Teen boy on mountain bike ride with dad smiling after seeking support from The Holman Group insurance coverage