Therapy-Interfering Behaviors in Teens: Signs, Causes, and Treatment

Have you arranged therapy for your teen, only to find that they’re not really engaging with it? Perhaps they attend their appointment but barely speak, avoid difficult conversations, or don’t practice the skills their therapist suggests. You might be wondering whether therapy is helping at all, or what else you can do to support them.

These behaviors are sometimes known as “therapy-interfering behaviors in teens.” They aren’t necessarily signs that your teen doesn’t want to get better or is deliberately being difficult. Instead, there may be underlying reasons why taking part in therapy feels so challenging. 

Understanding what’s behind these behaviors can help you support your teen and work with their therapist to make treatment more effective. To help you in this process, this page explores:

  • What therapy-interfering behaviors are.
  • Common signs and examples of such behaviors.
  • Why teens may behave this way.
  • How parents can help their teens.
  • Where to find professional support.
Teenage girl sitting with her dad comforting her whilst she is overcoming shame-based social anxiety
Table of Contents

What Are Therapy-Interfering Behaviors in Teens? 

Teens in therapy may sometimes behave in ways that make it harder to take part in or benefit from treatment. These patterns are known as “therapy-interfering behaviors,” or “TIBs.”[1]

TIBs can happen before, during, or between sessions. Some are obvious, such as regularly arriving late, while others are more subtle.[1]

For example, imagine a teen begins seeing a therapist for anxiety. They attend their appointments but might: 

  • Feel uncomfortable talking to a new person (their therapist).
  • Avoid discussing their big fears.
  • Rarely speak about what’s really bothering them. 

Or, when their therapist suggests learning a new coping skill, they might change the subject or avoid practicing between sessions. While a teen can genuinely want to feel better, they may also find it difficult to engage with the support.

So, a TIB is any behavior, intentional or not, that gets in the way of productive therapy. Addressing these patterns with compassion and curiosity is important because active adolescent therapy participation is crucial for making progress.

Signs of Therapy-Interfering Behaviors in Teens 

There isn’t a definitive list of therapy-interfering behaviors. Anything that makes it harder for an adolescent and their therapist to engage in treatment could be considered therapy-interfering. 

Some behaviors are easier to spot than others. But the key is noticing patterns. Missing one appointment because your teen is ill may not be a problem, but regularly finding reasons to be late or avoid sessions might suggest something else is going on. 

Remember, TIBs may happen without the teen intending to behave in a certain way, which is why it’s important to think about overall patterns rather than one-off events.[2] The following are some examples of how TIBs can show up.

Avoiding Therapy Sessions

An adolescent might:[1][2]

  • Frequently miss or cancel appointments.
  • Arrive late or ask to leave early.
  • Make excuses to avoid attending sessions.
  • Refuse to show up.

Avoiding Difficult Conversations

Some teenagers attend therapy but find it hard to talk about what’s happening. This could look like:[1][2]

  • Giving very short answers (such as saying “I don’t know” or “fine”), or becoming unusually quiet or withdrawn.
  • Changing the subject or refusing to discuss certain experiences.
  • Talking so much about other things that important topics are avoided.
  • Making jokes or using sarcasm to avoid talking about difficult feelings.
  • Saying things are “okay” when they clearly aren’t, perhaps to avoid getting into trouble.
  • Threatening to quit therapy.

Not Doing Therapy Activities or Homework

Depending on the approach, therapy may involve practicing skills between appointments, such as by tracking moods, using relaxation techniques, or completing worksheets. 

But a teen might regularly avoid these activities, saying they forgot or didn’t have time.[1][2] While this may be genuine during a particularly busy week, repeated avoidance could slow their progress.

Becoming Defensive or Argumentative

Sessions can involve discussing difficult experiences, recognizing unhelpful behavior, or considering making changes.

If teens feel criticized or uncomfortable, they may become defensive. This might show up in their behavior, such as:[1][2]

  • Arguing with their therapist.
  • Becoming angry, hostile, or dismissive.
  • Using aggressive or disrespectful language.
  • Rejecting every suggestion or blaming others.
  • Insisting they don’t need to change. 

Therapist Relationship Issues

The relationship between a teenager and their therapist is an important part of treatment. If a teen doesn’t feel understood, comfortable, or respected, they may find it difficult to engage. 

For example, they might:[1]

  • Believe their therapist is judging them.
  • Feel as though their therapist doesn’t understand their experiences.
  • Refuse to answer personal questions.
  • Insist that therapy isn’t helping.

Are You or a Loved One Struggling with Self Harm?

Mission Prep is here to help you or your loved one take the next steps towards an improved mental well-being.

three young women | Mission Prep Healthcare

Causes of Therapy-Interfering Behaviors in Teens

Often, therapy-interfering behaviors in adolescents are linked to the difficulties that brought them to therapy in the first place. Let’s look at some reasons why these behaviors might happen.

Overwhelm

Your teen may behave in certain ways to cope with overwhelm. For example, avoiding therapy activities between sessions could ease a fear of failure: they can’t fail at something they haven’t tried.

Vulnerability

Therapy can involve facing painful or complex emotions or revisiting traumatic memories. Plus, specific topics might bring up feelings of shame or leave teens feeling extremely vulnerable. So, to try and protect themselves, they may put up a “shield” – changing the subject, becoming quiet, deflecting, or shutting down – when things feel too raw. They might even skip sessions after a sensitive topic is discussed, such as self-harming.

Trust

Trust is also essential to therapy, but it takes time to develop. Some teens might worry that their therapist will tell their parents everything they say, or that their concerns won’t be taken seriously, which can make opening up feel harder.

Lack of Autonomy

Teen therapy resistance may also stem from feeling forced to attend because another adult – whether a parent, caregiver, or someone at school – has decided they need help. Feeling as though they don’t have a choice might lead teens to refuse to take part.

Mental Health Symptoms

Sometimes, symptoms of mental health conditions can make therapy harder and result in therapy-interfering behaviors in teens. For instance, low energy and lack of motivation associated with depression may make it harder for a teen to attend sessions or complete activities. Or, a teen with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) might have trouble focusing on or remembering tasks. On the other hand, an adolescent with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) who finds uncertainty difficult to handle could become caught up in repeating questions or seeking reassurance.[3]

Therapist Approach

Not every therapy approach works for every teenager. For example:
  • The therapist’s approach may not suit them.
  • Activities might feel too difficult.
  • Sessions could feel too formal.
  • Sensory overwhelm may become distracting.
  • They may feel their concerns aren’t being addressed.
In these situations, the treatment approach may need adapting, or different options may need to be explored. Remember, TIBs aren’t necessarily an act of rebellion. Your teen may not even be aware of these behaviors or understand why they’re happening. Often, they’re unconscious or protective responses, not something to be punished or ashamed of. Exploring them in therapy can help your teen make progress.[1]

How to Help With Therapy-Interfering Behaviors in Teens

Therapy-interfering behaviors in a teen’s treatment can affect their progress, which is why counselors address these patterns with compassion and curiosity. Parents can also help their teens work through these patterns outside the therapy room. For instance, here are some ways to support your teen’s mental health treatment:[4]
    • Avoid punishing your teen for TIBs: If you punish your teen for shutting down in therapy, they may begin to associate treatment with punishment, making it even harder for them to engage with it.
      • Maintain boundaries around therapy: Make sure they attend their appointments, even if they choose to sit in silence for the entire session.
      • Speak respectfully about their treatment: Avoid criticizing the therapist or dismissing the skills they’re learning from them in front of your teen.
      • Maintain consistency: If your teen has activities to do between sessions, help them make time for these.
      • Listen to your teen: If they complain about therapy, acknowledge their frustration and listen to how they feel, while still encouraging them to attend.
      • Praise their efforts: Notice and encourage your teen when they use a coping skill or complete therapy activities.
      • Check in with their therapist: Ask how things are progressing and raise any concerns you have.
      Remember, TIBs don’t necessarily mean therapy isn’t working. In fact, they can give your teen and their therapist an opportunity to explore what’s getting in the way of progress and find new ways to move forward.
      Every teen deserves to thrive

      We’re here to help them learn the skills to manage Self Harm & find their way back to themselves. There is no commitment required. Just an honest, confidential conversation about the support your family needs. Let’s take the first step together.

      "*" indicates required fields

      Find Adolescent Mental Health Support With Mission Prep Teen Treatment

      When your teen seems reluctant to engage in therapy, it can be difficult to know how to best support them. You might worry that they’re not making progress or wonder whether treatment is right for them.

      But therapy-interfering behaviors don’t have to mean your teen can’t benefit from support. With the right approach, you and your teen can begin to understand what’s getting in the way and find ways to move forward.  

      At Mission Prep Teen Treatment, we support teens and their families using evidence-based approaches, such as individual therapy and family therapy. Our mental health treatment programs are available on a residential or virtual outpatient basis so that your teen can get the level of care that best meets their needs.

      Mission Prep Teen Treatment accepts insurance and is in-network with many major providers. We are happy to help you check your insurance coverage for mental health care.

      Learn more about Mission Prep Teen Treatment and how we can help support you and your family by calling us at 866-901-4047. Our compassionate team is available 24/7 to answer your questions and provide guidance with no obligation.

      If you feel more comfortable, you can also reach out to us by sending us a message.

      Teenage girl in classroom standing with arms crossed smiling after receiving support for teen climate anxiety