
Knowing who you are as a person is hard enough in the teenage years when school, social life, and hormones seem to be pulling you in every direction. But knowing who you are when your identity spans cultures, languages, and worlds that don’t always align can be overwhelming.
For many, cultural identity development as a teenager can bring immense pressure to assimilate and precious little room to come as you are. But the link between belonging and mental health in adolescents is well established. Young people who feel they fit somewhere tend to fare better across nearly every measure of well-being.
To help explain how strong cultural identity in teens can provide a buffer against depression, anxiety, and low self-worth, this article will explore:
Bicultural teens experience things that can be hard to talk about or put into words, belonging to two separate cultures and sometimes feeling accepted by neither.
Research around teen identity and culture has described a process of constant, stressful negotiation around this.[1] For example, at school, a teen might suppress the cultural expressions that they worry will make them stand out to their peers.
At home, they might feel pressure to maintain traditions and expectations that are in conflict with who they are outside of the home. Code-switching between these worlds takes a lot of effort and can contribute to worsening mental health over time.[2]
However, no two experiences are exactly alike, and some young people are able to move between cultures easily. But for those who find this difficult, there can be an ongoing feeling that there is nowhere in which all of who they are is truly welcome.
Cultural identity in teens can be especially hard because identity formation is already one of the main challenges of this stage of life. The renowned developmental psychologist Erik Erikson described adolescence as a stage of identity versus role confusion, or a time when teens are working out who they are and where they fit.[3]
For bicultural teens, this already-complex process can play out across several cultural frameworks at the same time, each with its own expectations around:
When teen self-understanding and culture become intertwined, it can leave some young people unsure which parts of themselves belong to which world.
Adolescent belonging struggles can show up in several ways and in many environments. Your child may no longer want to go to school or may suddenly become quiet and reserved around the house.
The peer belonging issues teens experience with cultural identity can also be compounded by how hard they are to talk about. A teenager might not be able to articulate their experience, but they know something feels off. The inability to explain what is happening can then make the experience even more isolating.
Adolescent self-concept and belonging are deeply intertwined, with many teens caught between being apart from their peers and being too assimilated with their community.
This can cause a unique and painful type of loneliness, with nowhere feeling like a place that’s truly home. For some teens, this sense of not fitting in can really start to shape how they see themselves and their place in the world.
Many multicultural teens face explicit or implicit pressure to minimize their cultural identity in order to fit in. Peers may not understand or make fun of their backgrounds, and adults around them might treat cultural differences as something to ignore instead of celebrate.
Support for multicultural teens requires recognizing these pressures, as asking a young person to leave parts of who they are outside the door can be confusing and harmful to their overall self-concept. Being asked or expected to choose between cultures can have serious and long-lasting impacts on mental health and overall well-being.
Teen self-understanding and culture can quickly get complicated when family and peers are pulling in opposite directions. A teen whose family holds strong traditional values can find themselves in direct conflict with the social norms and expectations of their friends and classmates. This conflict can leave teens feeling disloyal, whichever direction they lean, creating a lot of guilt and confusion.
Discrimination is a measurable stressor on young people, with outsized consequences. The cumulative effect of discrimination can erode a young person’s sense of safety and self-worth.
Teenagers who experience racial or ethnic discrimination carry additional burdens in daily life, with research linking these experiences directly to increased rates of depression, anxiety, and lower academic achievement.[4]
Some teens grow to feel ashamed of the parts of their identity that they feel make them stand out as different.
A teenager who has taken in the message that their heritage is something they need to hide can carry that shame everywhere, shaping how much of themselves they are willing to show the world around them.
This internalized shame can even become a barrier to forming close relationships, as they may fear that revealing their full self will lead to rejection.
Minority teens, whether defined by race, ethnicity, religion, sexuality, or cultural background, face stressors that are often invisible to those who don’t share their experiences.
They also often face them without enough professional support, in part because the mental health field has historically done a poor job of meeting them where they are.
Cultural stigma and access have typically served as barriers. Even when multicultural teens get in the door, clinicians who lack cultural competence can accidentally pathologize normal cultural experiences and miss the significance of unique family and community dynamics. Mental health and cultural identity are deeply connected, and treatment that ignores this connection is unlikely to be effective.
Teen counseling for identity struggles is most effective when the therapist is experienced and curious about a young person’s cultural context as central to how they see themselves. A teen who feels seen by their counselor is much more likely to engage honestly in the therapeutic process.
Unaddressed cultural identity struggles can have a significant impact on mental health. Depression, anxiety, rising stress levels, and low self-esteem can all take root in the teenage years on their own, and can be both caused by and exacerbated by acculturative and social stressors to fit in.
Helping teens feel accepted within the clinical context means making space where their full identity and personhood are welcomed, and their cultural values are respected. Helping them explore the reasons for how they feel, putting language to it, and becoming curious about how to affirm themselves can be life-changing work during a challenging time.
Mission Prep is here to help you or your loved one take the next steps towards an improved mental well-being.
For an adolescent who has spent years feeling caught between worlds, therapy can offer a space where they don’t need to code-switch or perform. Therapy for identity issues and teens dealing with belonging challenges can help them explore who they are. It provides an opportunity to examine the pressures they face without judgment and to begin building a true sense of self.
The right approach depends on what the teen is dealing with. Some need to process experiences of discrimination or feelings of exclusion, while others need support in building a sense of identity with multiple influences. Some teens may need help managing the anxiety or depression that has developed alongside their identity challenges.
A clinician who understands the pressures of navigating multiple cultural influences and doesn’t treat Western norms as the default is foundational for healing. Cultural competence in practice means the therapist:
For teens who have potentially spent years being misunderstood, sitting with someone who gets it can be incredibly beneficial. Teen counseling for identity struggles sends a powerful message that all of who they are makes sense, and that their experiences are worth something and taken seriously. This validation alone can begin to change how a teen sees themselves and their place in the world.
Narrative therapy is well-suited to work around adolescent self-concept and belonging because it centers the teen’s own story. It invites them to examine the narratives they’ve absorbed and identify which of those stories actually belong to them.
This process can give them a new outlook for reclaiming authorship of their own identity rather than having to live inside a story imposed by the pressures they face. For bicultural teens especially, narrative therapy can help them see that holding multiple identities is a positive thing to be embraced.
For many minority teens, family can be a constant source of both belonging and tension. Bringing family members into the process can be a way to explore the relational dynamics that shape a teen’s experiences, making room for everyone’s perspective and allowing for more open communication and sharing.
Family therapy can also help parents understand the specific pressures their teen faces in navigating between cultural worlds. This can help foster more empathy and support at home.
Mission Prep provides treatment for teens experiencing various mental health conditions. Mental Health support is a phone call away – call 866-901-4047 to learn about your treatment options.
See our residences in Southern California’s Los Angeles & San Diego areas.
View our facilities in Loudoun County, VA within the DC metro area.
Identity struggles can also contribute to and coexist with mental health conditions. Early intervention and more intensive treatment when appropriate can produce much better outcomes in the long run.[5]
Mission Prep Teen Treatment offers multiple levels of care, including outpatient treatment, intensive outpatient care, and inpatient/residential treatment for young people and their families. If your teenager is having difficulty with their mental health, then they deserve all the support they need to figure things out and start the recovery process.
Our expert clinicians understand the relationship between cultural identity and mental health. At each of our locations, we work to create an environment where every teen feels seen and understood.
If you’d like to learn more about treatment options for your teen, call 866-901-4047. Our caring team is available 24/7 to answer your questions and help you determine what support would be best for your adolescent. Contact us anytime for a free, no obligation conversation.
"*" indicates required fields
100% Confidential
No Commitment
Instant Results
Yes. Cultural identity development for teenagers is a natural and healthy part of adolescent development. Teenagers are supposed to question, experiment, and push back against inherited identities as they form their own. If confusion or chronic stress has caused isolation or other mental health concerns, then they could benefit from professional help to explore their experiences.
Watch out for changes in behavior that seem different from their normal routines. Your child might withdraw from family and friends, stop doing well in school, lose interest in things they used to enjoy, or seem disinterested and disengaged. If these changes last for more than a few weeks and don’t seem tied to a specific event, it’s worth talking about what’s going on and how therapy and support can help them through. Persistent changes in mood, sleep, appetite, or social life are all signs that professional support may be beneficial.
Do your best to listen to their concerns without an agenda. Parents who approach conversations like this tend to help their child more with feeling heard and understood. Helping teens feel accepted at home means letting them express ambivalence and ask hard questions, along with being mindful of your own assumptions about assimilation, success, and belonging.
It can, especially when the clinician is experienced and knowledgeable in acculturative concerns. Teen counseling for identity struggles is about providing a safe place to explore these issues. The right therapy can help a teen develop a stronger sense of who they are across all of the cultures they belong to.
Are You Covered for Mental Health Treatment?
We’re in-network with many providers. Call us at 866-901-4047 to verify your benefits and find out how much your plan will cover
Find out if Mission Prep is right for you by reaching out to us and speaking with one of our admissions representatives.